Eagle’s Landing Lodge tops our list with a 9.6 guest score and prime location near Mt. Rushmore. For historic charm and a 9.7 rating, EO Bungalows, Black Hills delivers walk-in showers and a garden. Both cater to different styles of Custer exploration.
Finding a room near Custer SD feels like striking gold in the Black Hills — here are 15 properties that actually earn their stay.
Why Trust This Guide
I analyzed 2,000+ guest reviews across these 15 properties, filtering for scores above 8.0 and prioritizing cleanliness and location ratings to match Custer’s outdoor-driven travel patterns.
🎯 Quick Picks: Skip to What You Need
- Highest Rated: #9 EO Bungalows→ Rates
#7 Eagle’s Landing Lodge→ Rates - Best for Families: #2 Bavarian Inn→ Rates
- Best Value Motel: #5 Rocket Motel→ Rates
- Pet-Friendly (Request Only): #15 Bearded Buffalo Resort→ Rates
- Best Location Score: #9 EO Bungalows, Black Hills→ Rates
- Full Kitchen Needed: #10 Renegade Log Cabin→ Rates
Editor’s Note on Booking: We use smart routing to find you the best available rates. Clicking our availability buttons checks live pricing across trusted platforms to ensure you secure your stay.
Quick Compare: Top Places To Stay
| Property | Rating | Book |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Chalet Motel | (500+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 2. Bavarian Inn, Black Hills | (450+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 3. Comfort Inn & Suites | (450+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 4. Chief Motel | (350+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 5. Rocket Motel | (350+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 6. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Custer-Mt Rushmore | (300+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 7. Eagle’s Landing Lodge | (250+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 8. Rock Crest Lodge & Cabins | (250+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 9. EO Bungalows, Black Hills | (150+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 10. Renegade Log Cabin | (10+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 11. Johnny Cash “Rambler” on Main | (10+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 12. Hot Shot Hideaway | (10+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 13. Camp Bluebird | (10+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 14. Shop, Hike & Explore! Historic Dtwn Custer Apt | (10+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 15. Bearded Buffalo Resort | (10+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
Detailed Reviews: 15 Places to Stay Near Custer SD
1. Chalet Motel
The Vibe
A no-fuss motel on Mt. Rushmore Road with a 9.4 location score that puts you steps from downtown Custer dining. The garden and outdoor seating area are quiet retreats after a day in the Black Hills, though the 8.5 overall rating shows it’s basic — not flashy.
What You Actually Get
Each room comes with a tea and coffee maker, refrigerator, and free toiletries. Air-conditioning keeps things cool during summer trips. The motel offers free private parking, on-site bicycle parking, and a picnic area. Breakfast is continental with a grab-and-go option — fine for fueling up before hitting Mt. Rushmore, 30 minutes away. Note that check-in cuts off at 21:00, so plan arrival timing.
Choose this if: You want a cheap, central base with a solid 9.4 location and don’t need frills.
2. Bavarian Inn, Black Hills
The Vibe
A family-favorite motel with two pools (indoor and outdoor) and a 9.6 location score. The Bavarian theme is charming without being kitschy. Guests consistently praise the cleanliness and the breakfast spread, which includes vegetarian, vegan, gluten-free, and American options. Crazy Horse Memorial is a short drive.
What You Actually Get
Rooms come with free WiFi, cable TV, a microwave, and a fridge. Check-in runs until 22:00, giving you flexibility after a long drive from Rapid City. The property allows pets, has on-site free parking, and serves a continental breakfast with dietary accommodations. The indoor pool is a hit with kids, while the outdoor one opens seasonally. Unlike basic motels, this one feels like a destination in itself.
Choose this if: You’re traveling with kids and want a 9.3-rated property that doubles as an activity stop.
3. Comfort Inn & Suites
The Vibe
A reliable 3-star hotel with a solid 8.4 rating and a location score of 9.2. The indoor swimming pool and hot tub are major draws during colder months. The free American buffet breakfast — featuring pancakes, pastries, and fresh fruits — gets consistent praise from guests.
What You Actually Get
Rooms have air-conditioning, free WiFi, and a 24-hour front desk for late arrivals. The hotel offers free parking, a business center, and general wellness facilities. The hot tub is a nice reset after hiking in the Black Hills. Unlike the motels lower on this list, this one provides a more structured hotel experience with a consistent brand standard, though it lacks the character of the Bavarian Inn or the bungalows.
Choose this if: You want a hot breakfast and a guaranteed indoor pool-open anytime.
4. Chief Motel
The Vibe
A 2-star motel that punches above its weight with a 9.3 location score and an indoor pool, hot tub, and sauna. The sun terrace and garden offer outdoor seating. With only 350+ reviews and an 8.6 rating, it’s a solid mid-range pick for budget-conscious travelers.
What You Actually Get
Rooms are basic but clean: a desk, flat-screen TV, and private bathroom. The pool, hot tub, and sauna are only available from May 20 to September 21 — confirm dates before booking if those amenities are your priority. Free WiFi and on-site private parking included. The motel offers family rooms, making it a viable option for small groups. Check-in starts at 14:00, an hour earlier than most competitors.
Choose this if: You want an early check-in (14:00) and seasonal pool access without the price tag.
5. Rocket Motel
The Vibe
A 9.2-rated motel with a 9.6 location score and a covered pavilion with BBQ facilities and a fire pit. Guests love the retro vibe and the sleep quality. It’s a 30-minute drive to Mt. Rushmore, making it a favorite for travelers who want a communal outdoor space to wind down.
What You Actually Get
Each air-conditioned room has a flat-screen cable TV, microwave, small refrigerator, and hairdryer. Free WiFi is included. The fire pit is a standout feature — you won’t find this at the Comfort Inn. The motel offers free private parking and bicycle parking. Unlike the Bavarian Inn, there’s no pool, but the outdoor pavilion more than compensates for evening hangs.
Choose this if: You value a 9.6 location, a communal hangout space, and excellent sleep quality.
6. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Custer-Mt Rushmore
The Vibe
A branded hotel with an 8.6 rating and a 9.1 location score. The indoor swimming pool, hot tub, and fitness centre make it a reliable pick for families. The sun terrace and outdoor fireplace add a touch of warmth. The American buffet breakfast is included.
What You Actually Get
Family rooms with private bathrooms, air-conditioning, and free WiFi. Each room includes a work desk, TV, and wardrobe. The hotel offers on-site free parking, a lounge, and an outdoor fireplace. Unlike the Rocket Motel, this one has a fitness centre — great for maintaining routines on the road. The 24-hour front desk means late arrivals are no issue.
Choose this if: You want a predictable hotel experience with a gym and pool.
Check Tonight’s Price for Holiday Inn Express & Suites Custer-Mt Rushmore →
7. Eagle’s Landing Lodge
The Vibe
A 5-star lodge on U.S. 16 with a 9.6 rating and a 9.6 location score. The sun terrace, lounge, outdoor fireplace, and shared kitchen create a communal luxury vibe. Balconies and kitchenettes make this feel more like a high-end rental than a hotel.
What You Actually Get
Air-conditioned rooms with kitchenettes, private bathrooms, and balconies. Free WiFi and on-site parking included. A damage deposit of $70 is required via credit card upon arrival, reimbursed at check-out. Some rooms allow pets. The lodge offers private check-in/check-out, an outdoor fireplace, and a shared kitchen. Unlike the Bavarian Inn, this is more adult-oriented — no pools, but plenty of quiet luxury.
Choose this if: You want a 9.6-rated lodge with kitchenettes and a balcony overlooking the Black Hills.
8. Rock Crest Lodge & Cabins
The Vibe
A hotel with cabin-style vibes and an 8.2 rating. The pool with a view and sun terrace are the main draws. Location score of 8.7 is decent but lower than most on this list. The property offers a hot tub and continental breakfast.
What You Actually Get
Rooms come with air-conditioning, a tea and coffee maker, refrigerator, and free toiletries. Free WiFi throughout. The pool overlook is notable — it’s not just a standard pool, it’s positioned for views. Continental breakfast is served mornings. Check-in doesn’t start until 16:00, the latest on this list. Unlike the Rocket Motel, there’s no fire pit, but the hot tub compensates.
Choose this if: You want a pool with a view and don’t mind a later 16:00 check-in.
9. EO Bungalows, Black Hills
The Vibe
The highest-rated property on our list at 9.7, with a perfect 9.8 location score. Housed in a historic building on North 7th Street, it combines charm with modern walk-in showers. The garden and outdoor fireplace create a serene downtown retreat.
What You Actually Get
Rooms feature air-conditioning, private bathrooms with walk-in showers, and comfortable beds — guests specifically note the mattress quality. The property includes a garden, outdoor fireplace, and free parking. You’ll need to notify them of your arrival time in advance. Unlike Eagle’s Landing Lodge, this one doesn’t have a shared kitchen, but the historic character and 9.8 location are unmatched.
Choose this if: Places to stay near Custer SD should hit perfection — this is the one for location and charm.
10. Renegade Log Cabin
The Vibe
A ground-floor log cabin with a 9.3 rating and 9.8 location. The fully equipped kitchen (refrigerator, microwave, dishwasher, oven, stovetop, toaster) makes it ideal for self-catering. The outdoor seating area and patio add a private retreat feel.
What You Actually Get
One-bedroom unit with a living room, dining area, and outdoor furniture. Free WiFi and on-site parking. Check-in has a strict window of 15:00 to 18:30 — the tightest on the list. Unlike the Johnny Cash Rambler, this one focuses on homey functionality over gimmicks. Good for couples who want to cook their own meals.
Choose this if: You want a true cabin experience with cooking facilities and a 9.8 location.
11. Johnny Cash “Rambler” on Main
The Vibe
A one-bedroom apartment on Mt. Rushmore Road with a perfect 10.0 location score and a 9.5 rating. The private pool, spa bath, and mountain views are luxury touches. It’s named after the Man in Black — expect eclectic decor.
What You Actually Get
Spacious apartment with a kitchenette, living room, washing machine, air-conditioning, and free WiFi. The private pool is rare for a rental unit — most hotels don’t offer this. A sofa bed adds flexibility for a third guest. Check-in is from 16:00, and advance notice of arrival is required. Unlike the Bavarian Inn, this is purely self-contained — no reception desk, no breakfast.
Choose this if: You want a unique, music-themed apartment with a private pool and 10.0 location.
12. Hot Shot Hideaway
The Vibe
A spacious three-bedroom holiday home on Lower French Creek Road with a 9.7 rating and perfect 10.0 location. The balcony offers garden and mountain views. With 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, it’s built for groups.
What You Actually Get
Fully equipped kitchen with dishwasher, microwave, and oven. Free WiFi, air-conditioning, and on-site parking. Pets are allowed, making it one of the few group-friendly pet options. Check-in is from 16:00. Unlike the Renegade Log Cabin, this one gives you more space and views, but with a stricter cancellation policy.
Choose this if: You’re a group of 6+ needing space, views, and pet-friendly policies.
13. Camp Bluebird
The Vibe
A two-bedroom holiday home on Bluebird Lane with a 9.6 rating and 9.7 location. The patio and outdoor dining area make it feel like a true camp. Located 35 km from Mt. Rushmore — further out than most, but quieter.
What You Actually Get
Two bedrooms, two bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen with dishwasher and microwave, a washing machine, and free WiFi. The patio and outdoor dining area are the standouts — perfect for summer evenings. Free private parking on-site. Unlike the Hot Shot Hideaway, this one is smaller and more intimate, suited for couples or small families.
Choose this if: You want a quiet, self-contained home with a patio for outdoor meals.
14. Shop, Hike & Explore! Historic Dtwn Custer Apt
The Vibe
A three-bedroom apartment in downtown Custer with a 9.1 rating and 9.6 location. The spa and wellness centre adds a luxurious twist. It includes a fireplace, coffee machine, and private entrance. Ideal for those who want to walk to shops and trails.
What You Actually Get
Fully equipped kitchen, air-conditioning, private entrance, and free WiFi. The spa features are a nice bonus — not common in downtown apartments. Check-in is from 15:00. Unlike the Johnny Cash Rambler, this one focuses on location and space over novelty. Free on-site parking included.
Choose this if: You need three bedrooms and want to be in the thick of downtown Custer.
Check Tonight’s Price for Shop, Hike & Explore! Historic Dtwn Custer Apt →
15. Bearded Buffalo Resort
The Vibe
A 9.5-rated apartment on U.S. 16A with a perfect 10.0 location. The sun terrace, garden, and mountain views create a resort-like feel. Pets are allowed upon request with a $125 per stay fee. 24-hour check-in is a lifesaver for late arrivals.
What You Actually Get
Air-conditioned apartment with a fully equipped kitchen, private bathroom with walk-in shower, and a washing machine. Free WiFi and on-site parking included. The property offers private check-in/check-out. Unlike the Holiday Inn Express, this one lets you check in at 2 AM if needed. Pets require prior approval and a $125 fee.
Choose this if: You’re arriving late, bringing a pet, or want a 10.0-location apartment with mountain views.
Final Verdict: Our Top 3 Picks
🏆 Best Overall
#9 EO Bungalows, Black Hills
The 9.7 rating and 9.8 location score are the highest combo on this list, with historic charm and walk-in showers.
💰 Best Value
#5 Rocket Motel
A 9.2 rating, 9.6 location, and fire pit access without the high price tag — quality-to-cost ratio is unmatched.
👨👩👧 Best for Families
#2 Bavarian Inn, Black Hills
Two pools, a breakfast that covers dietary needs, and a 9.3 rating make it the clear family pick.
How We Ranked These Custer Hotels
We evaluated 15 properties near Custer SD using 2,000+ guest reviews, filtering for overall scores above 8.0 and prioritizing location and cleanliness to match the outdoor-focused travel patterns of Black Hills visitors.
- Guest score thresholds: Only properties with 8.0+ overall and 10+ verified reviews
- Score breakdown analysis: Prioritized cleanliness, location, and value — the categories that drive repeat bookings
- Amenity verification: Cross-referenced advertised amenities against guest review patterns
- Location signals: Distance to Mt. Rushmore, Crazy Horse, and downtown Custer walkability
Frequently Asked Questions
Are pets allowed at these Custer hotels?
Yes, several properties on this list accommodate pets. The Bearded Buffalo Resort (H15) allows pets with prior approval and a $125 fee per stay. Eagle’s Landing Lodge (H7) and Hot Shot Hideaway (H12) also permit pets — confirmed at booking. The Bavarian Inn (H2) has pet-friendly policies as well. Always confirm directly, as some properties charge per night rather than per stay.
Which hotels offer free cancellation near Custer SD?
Most chain hotels like Comfort Inn & Suites (H3) and Holiday Inn Express (H6) offer flexible cancellation policies, often up to 24-48 hours before arrival. Smaller motels like Chalet Motel (H1) and Rocket Motel (H5) have varied policies — check the specific rate when booking. The holiday homes (H10-H15) tend to have stricter cancellation terms due to their limited inventory.
Can I check in late at any of these properties?
The Bearded Buffalo Resort (H15) offers 24-hour check-in, making it the best option for late arrivals. Eagle’s Landing Lodge (H7) accepts check-ins until midnight. Most motels like Chalet Motel (H1) and Rocket Motel (H5) cut off at 21:00-22:00. EO Bungalows (H9) requires advance notice of your arrival time — contact them directly if arriving after 22:00.
What’s the best time to visit Custer, South Dakota?
June through September offers the best weather for exploring the Black Hills — temperatures sit between 70-85°F, and all seasonal amenities (like Chief Motel’s pool and sauna, available May 20-Sept 21) are operational. July and August are peak crowds around Mt. Rushmore. May and October are quieter but cooler, with some properties like Rock Crest Lodge ending seasonal pool access.
Which area of Custer is most walkable for hotels?
The downtown core around Mt. Rushmore Road and North 5th Street is the most walkable. EO Bungalows (H9) with its 9.8 location score sits on North 7th Street, steps from restaurants and shops. Chalet Motel (H1) and Rocket Motel (H5) are also on Mt. Rushmore Road, offering easy access to Custer’s main dining and retail strip. Properties on U.S. 16 or U.S. 16A (like Eagle’s Landing Lodge and Bearded Buffalo Resort) require a car.
What’s the most popular places to stay near Custer SD for couples?
For couples, EO Bungalows (H9) leads with a 9.7 rating and historic ambiance. Eagle’s Landing Lodge (H7) offers 5-star lodge vibes with balcony views. The Renegade Log Cabin (H10) is ideal for couples who want a private, kitchen-equipped cabin with a 9.8 location score. Avoid the larger family-oriented properties like Bavarian Inn or Holiday Inn Express if you’re seeking a quieter, more romantic stay.