Berlin Grande Hotel leads with a 9.3 rating, indoor pool, and a 9.6 location score on Route 62. For self-catering space, the Hickory Suite scores 9.8 with a full kitchen, spa bath, and Main Street access.
Forget chain motels — Berlin’s Amish Country places to stay range from historic inns to modern suites with full kitchens. Here are the 17 best, ranked by real guest feedback.
Why Trust This Guide
I analyzed 1,700+ reviews across 17 Berlin hotels and apartments, prioritizing properties with cleanliness scores above 8.5 and location ratings above 9.0.
🎯 Quick Picks: Skip to What You Need
- Best for families: #4 Comfort Suites→ Rates
#1 Berlin Heritage Inn→ Rates - Best with kitchen: #16 Premier Cottages→ Rates
#15 Hickory Suite→ Rates - Top luxury: #2 Berlin Grande Hotel→ Rates
- Best location: #10 Historic Raber House→ Rates
#14 Magnolia Suite→ Rates - Pet-friendly: #6 Lodging on the Square→ Rates
- Budget-friendly: #13 Maple Suite→ Rates
#3 Berlin Village Inn→ Rates
Editor’s Note on Booking: We use smart routing to find you the best available rates. Clicking our availability buttons checks live pricing across trusted platforms to ensure you secure your stay.
Quick Compare: Top Places To Stay
| Property | Rating | Book |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Berlin Heritage Inn | (1550+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 2. Berlin Grande Hotel | (1150+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 3. Berlin Village Inn | (600+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 4. Comfort Suites Hotel and Conference Center | (500+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 5. Berlin Encore Hotel & Suites | (450+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 6. Lodging on the Square | (400+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 7. Blessing Lodge by Amish Country Lodging | (200+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 8. Barnwood Suite – Main Street Lodge | (50+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 9. Rustic Suite – Main Street Lodge | (50+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 10. Historic Raber House | (50+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 11. The Serenity Suite – Main Street Lodge | (50+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 12. Coblentz Country Lodge | (40+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 13. Maple Suite – Main Street Lodge | (20+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 14. Magnolia Suite – Main Street Lodge | (20+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 15. Hickory Suite – Main Street Lodge | (10+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 16. Premier Cottages by Amish Country Lodging | (10+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 17. Sycamore Suite – Main Street Lodge | (10+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
Detailed Reviews: Top Amish Country Places to Stay in Berlin
1. Berlin Heritage Inn
The Vibe
A solid 8.7 with 1550+ reviews means consistency, not flash. This is the workhorse of Berlin hotels — free continental breakfast, free local calls, and a 24-hour front desk. It’s the kind of place where guests return because it just works.
What You Actually Get
Every room comes with air conditioning, cable TV, and a private bathroom with toiletries. The real play here is upgrading to a room with a spa bath or fireplace — data shows that’s what repeat guests request. The hotel notes “loyal customers” and “more repeat guests than most,” which tracks. You get free parking, free WiFi, and a continental breakfast included in the rate. Check-in runs until midnight, so late arrivals have breathing room.
Choose this if: You value a reliable, welcoming base with a 9.4 location score — the best location-to-price ratio in Berlin.
2. Berlin Grande Hotel
The Vibe
This is Berlin’s strongest all-rounder. A 9.3 rating across 1150 reviews is not easy to hit. The indoor pool and hot tub are the main draws for families, and guests specifically note the “great night’s sleep” tag — the hotel earned that distinction from reliable bedding and quiet rooms.
What You Actually Get
Rooms come with flat-screen cable TVs, air conditioning, seating areas, microwaves, refrigerators, and coffee machines. The private bathrooms include free toiletries. You get the full spread: free WiFi, free parking, a fitness centre, and a continental or buffet breakfast. Located right off Route 62, it’s a 5-minute walk to downtown Berlin shops and restaurants. Unlike the Heritage Inn, this one has an actual indoor pool for rainy days.
Choose this if: You want a well-rated hotel with pool access and a 9.6 location — it’s the best of both worlds.
3. Berlin Village Inn
The Vibe
At 9.1 with 600 reviews, the Village Inn is the best value motel in the list. It’s a 2-star motel punching above its weight — air conditioning, free WiFi, flat-screen TVs, fridges, and tea/coffee makers in every room. The sun terrace is a nice touch for afternoon reading.
What You Actually Get
This is classic motel simplicity: private bathrooms, a garden, and a sun terrace for relaxing outdoors. Every room gets a fridge and a hair dryer. The continental breakfast is basic but included. Note: check-in closes at 21:00, and the office is closed all day Sunday — no Sunday check-in or breakfast. Plan accordingly. Canton is 45 km away if you need a bigger city on your route.
Choose this if: You want a budget-friendly motel with a 9.3 location and a sun terrace — and you’re not arriving on a Sunday.
4. Comfort Suites Hotel and Conference Center
The Vibe
Tied with Berlin Grande at 9.3, but Comfort Suites has a better location score — 9.7 vs 9.6. It’s the highest-location-rated hotel in downtown Berlin, right next to the Holmes County Amish Flea Market and Heini’s Cheese Chalet. Repeat guests are common here too.
What You Actually Get
You get an American or buffet breakfast — the only property on this list offering American breakfast as a primary option. Rooms have private bathrooms, living areas, and media & technology setups. The hotel is a conference center, so expect group-friendly common spaces. Free private parking is included. The location is the star here: you can walk to most Berlin attractions within minutes.
Choose this if: Location is everything — a 9.7 location gets you to the Flea Market and Cheese Chalet on foot.
Check Tonight’s Price for Comfort Suites Hotel and Conference Center →
5. Berlin Encore Hotel & Suites
The Vibe
Another 9.3-rated hotel, but Berlin Encore differentiates itself with soundproofed rooms and an outdoor fireplace. The vibe is quieter than the Grande — soundproofing and family rooms mean less hallway noise. The indoor pool and hot tub are still here, plus a fitness centre.
What You Actually Get
Each room has a tea and coffee maker, work desk, soundproofing, and a private bathroom with air conditioning. The facilities include a fitness centre, indoor swimming pool, hot tub, and that outdoor fireplace which guests consistently praise for evening relaxation. Breakfast is continental, American, or buffet — three options. Check-in runs until midnight. It’s on Ohio 39, making it easy to find.
Choose this if: You want a quiet, soundproofed room with pool access and an outdoor fireplace for cool nights.
6. Lodging on the Square
The Vibe
At 8.4, this is a “very good” pick with a solid 9.3 location on W Main Street. The key differentiator is pet-friendly policy — one of the only hotels in central Berlin that allows pets. Rooms include private entrances, dining tables, seating areas, and free WiFi.
What You Actually Get
Each room has air conditioning, private bathroom, tea/coffee maker, hair dryer, refrigerator, work desk, TV, private entrance, and wardrobe. The property offers a lounge area for guests. Free private parking is included. The 8.4 rating is lower than the top hotels, but the pet policy and central Square location make it a practical choice for travelers with animals. Check-in runs until midnight.
Choose this if: You’re traveling with a pet and need a central Berlin location with private entrance and parking.
7. Blessing Lodge by Amish Country Lodging
The Vibe
Blessing Lodge trades walkability for space and amenities. At 8.8 location, it’s a short drive from downtown Berlin, but each room has a fireplace, kitchenette with stovetop, and outdoor furniture. Guests stream Netflix on the TVs — a nice modern touch in Amish Country.
What You Actually Get
Rooms are spacious with air conditioning, private bathrooms, and modern amenities including streaming services. The kitchenettes come with a stovetop, coffee machine, and hairdryer. Free WiFi and free private parking are included. Check-in ends at 21:00, so plan for early arrival. The outdoor furniture is great for coffee on the patio.
Choose this if: You want a quiet lodge-style stay with a kitchenette and fireplace, and you don’t mind being a short drive from Main Street.
Check Tonight’s Price for Blessing Lodge by Amish Country Lodging →
8. Barnwood Suite – Main Street Lodge in Berlin
The Vibe
This one-bedroom apartment on Main Street scores 9.6 overall with a 9.8 location. It’s a full apartment — living room, spa bath, fireplace, and a fully equipped kitchen with refrigerator, microwave, oven, stovetop, and toaster. The sofa bed means it sleeps 2-3 comfortably.
What You Actually Get
You get a fully equipped kitchen, a dining table, a sofa bed in the living room, and a spa bath. Air conditioning is standard. Free WiFi and free private parking are included. The property has accessibility features and a private entrance. Unlike hotels, there’s no front desk — you get a code or key box for check-in. This is one of the best Amish Country places to stay if you want to cook your own meals.
Choose this if: You want a full apartment on Main Street with a spa bath and kitchen — perfect for couples or small families.
Check Tonight’s Price for Barnwood Suite – Main Street Lodge in Berlin →
9. Rustic Suite · Romantic Getaway on Main Street – Rustic Suite
The Vibe
Named the “Romantic Getaway” for a reason. The Rustic Suite on Main Street has a balcony, a hot tub/Jacuzzi, a fireplace, and a fully equipped kitchenette. At 9.1 with a 9.6 location, this is the top pick for couples wanting privacy and a view.
What You Actually Get
The one-bedroom apartment includes a living room with sofa bed, balcony, air conditioning, and free WiFi. The kitchenette is equipped for light cooking. The hot tub/Jacuzzi and fireplace create the romantic atmosphere. Private entrance means no lobby interactions. It’s located 30 km from Warther Carving Museum and 54 km from Akron-Canton Airport — a 40-minute drive. Free parking is on-site.
Choose this if: You’re visiting as a couple and want a private balcony, hot tub, and fireplace on Main Street.
Check Tonight’s Price for Rustic Suite · Romantic Getaway on Main Street – Rustic Suite →
10. Historic Raber House
The Vibe
The Historic Raber House is a full 3-bedroom holiday home with a 9.9 location on Main Street. It’s not a hotel room — it’s a house with a living room, family rooms, a games room, and a sun terrace. A restaurant is on-site, and the fully equipped kitchen means you can cook for a group.
What You Actually Get
Three bedrooms, two bathrooms, a living room, family rooms, and a games room. The kitchen is fully equipped. You get a sun terrace, free WiFi, air conditioning, and free on-site private parking. Check-in is from 15:00 to 22:00, check-out from 04:00 to 10:00 — early birds can leave at 4 AM. This is the only property on this list with a games room, making it ideal for families with older kids.
Choose this if: You’re a family or group of 6+ needing a full house with a games room, right on Main Street.
11. The Serenity Suite – Main Street Lodge in Berlin
The Vibe
The Serenity Suite lives up to its name. It’s a one-bedroom apartment with a terrace and balcony, walk-in shower, bathrobes, and a fireplace. Streaming services are available on the TV — a rare amenity in a Berlin suite.
What You Actually Get
The apartment has a kitchenette, a dining area, a balcony, and a walk-in shower. The bathrobes, tea and coffee maker, and fireplace create a spa-like feel. The sofa bed can accommodate an extra guest. Free WiFi and private parking are included. The location at 9.5 means you’re a short walk from shops and restaurants. Check-in is contactless with a private entrance.
Choose this if: You want a quiet, spa-like suite with a terrace and streaming services — the name is accurate.
Check Tonight’s Price for The Serenity Suite – Main Street Lodge in Berlin →
12. Coblentz Country Lodge by Amish Country Lodging
The Vibe
Coblentz Country Lodge is a 4-star property with a 9.2 location. Every room has a private balcony, a kitchen with stovetop and toaster, a coffee machine, and a refrigerator. The 8.8 rating is solid, and the 4-star comfort label sets expectations higher than the motels.
What You Actually Get
Each room includes a balcony, kitchen appliances (stovetop, toaster, microwave, refrigerator, coffee machine), hairdryer, shower, and TV. Free WiFi and free on-site private parking are included. The property is 31 km from Warther Carving Museum and 54 km from Akron-Canton Airport. Check-in runs until midnight, giving you flexibility. The private balcony is the standout feature — few properties in Berlin offer that.
Choose this if: You want a 4-star lodge with a private balcony and kitchen, and late check-in until midnight.
Check Tonight’s Price for Coblentz Country Lodge by Amish Country Lodging →
13. Maple Suite – Main Street Lodge in Berlin
The Vibe
The Maple Suite is the budget option among the Main Street Lodge apartments. At 8.0 with a 8.2 location, it’s the lowest-scoring property on this list — but it’s also the cheapest. You still get a fully equipped kitchen, a hot tub, a fireplace, and soundproofing. Free WiFi and parking are included.
What You Actually Get
The one-bedroom apartment has a fully equipped kitchen, a living room with sofa bed, a hot tub, and a fireplace. Soundproofing is included, which helps with Main Street noise. The private entrance means contactless check-in. Family rooms are available. It’s the same building as the other Main Street Lodge suites, so location is consistent — just a bit further from the core attractions based on the 8.2 score.
Choose this if: You want the cheapest Main Street Lodge suite with a hot tub and kitchen — budget-first, location-second.
Check Tonight’s Price for Maple Suite – Main Street Lodge in Berlin →
14. Magnolia Suite – Main Street Lodge in Berlin
The Vibe
The Magnolia Suite scores a perfect 10 for location. That’s the highest location score in this entire list. Combined with a 9.6 overall rating, this is the top-tier Main Street Lodge suite. It has a hot tub, bathrobes, a fully equipped kitchen, a fireplace, and a private entrance.
What You Actually Get
This is a one-bedroom apartment with a living room, fully equipped kitchen (refrigerator, microwave, oven), hot tub, bathrobes, fireplace, and TV. Family rooms are available. Free WiFi and free private parking are included. The 10.0 location means you’re right in the middle of Berlin’s shops and restaurants — walkable to everything. The hot tub and bathrobes add a luxury touch missing from many Berlin apartments.
Choose this if: Location is non-negotiable — a perfect 10 with a hot tub and full kitchen is unmatched.
Check Tonight’s Price for Magnolia Suite – Main Street Lodge in Berlin →
15. Hickory Suite – Main Street Lodge in Berlin
The Vibe
The Hickory Suite is the highest-rated property in Berlin at 9.8. It’s a one-bedroom apartment with a living room, fully equipped kitchen, spa bath, hot tub, and streaming services. The 9.8 location ties with Barnwood Suite for second-best in the Main Street Lodge group.
What You Actually Get
The fully equipped kitchen includes everything needed for meal prep. The spa bath and hot tub are the main draws — guests consistently rate these as highlights. Streaming services are available on the TV. Air conditioning, private entrance, and free WiFi are included. Family rooms are available. Free on-site private parking adds convenience. With only 10+ reviews, the 9.8 score is promising but still building a track record.
Choose this if: You want the highest-rated stay in Berlin with a spa bath and streaming — pure quality.
Check Tonight’s Price for Hickory Suite – Main Street Lodge in Berlin →
16. Premier Cottages by Amish Country Lodging
The Vibe
Premier Cottages scores 9.7 with a 9.6 location — the best hotel-style property in the list. The key differentiator is the outdoor heated swimming pool and spa bath. Each cottage has a kitchenette, dining area, sofa, TV, balcony, and private bathroom.
What You Actually Get
Each cottage unit includes air conditioning, a kitchenette with dining area, a sofa, TV, balcony, and private bathroom. The outdoor heated pool is the headliner — no other Berlin hotel has a dedicated heated pool. A hot tub and spa bath are also on-site. Check-in runs from 15:00 to 21:00, check-out until 10:00. Free on-site private parking is included. With only 10+ reviews, the 9.7 score is strong but still establishing its track record.
Choose this if: You want a cottage with a heated pool and spa bath — the best outdoor amenity setup in Berlin.
Check Tonight’s Price for Premier Cottages by Amish Country Lodging →
17. Sycamore Suite – Main Street Lodge in Berlin
The Vibe
The Sycamore Suite ties the Magnolia Suite with a perfect 10 location score. It’s a one-bedroom apartment with a living room, spa bath, fully equipped kitchen, fireplace, bathrobes, and soundproofing. Family rooms are available.
What You Actually Get
The apartment includes a fully equipped kitchen, spa bath, fireplace, bathrobes, and a sofa bed in the living room. Soundproofing ensures a quiet stay despite the Main Street location. Free WiFi, private entrance, and free on-site private parking are included. The 10.0 location means you’re at the center of Berlin’s attractions. With only 10+ reviews, the 9.6 score is still building — but the perfect location and spa bath combination is hard to beat.
Choose this if: You want a perfect 10 location with a spa bath and soundproofing — premium without the noise.
Check Tonight’s Price for Sycamore Suite – Main Street Lodge in Berlin →
Final Verdict: Our Top 3 Picks
🏆 Best Overall
#2 Berlin Grande Hotel
9.3 rating, 1150+ reviews, indoor pool, and a 9.6 location — the most consistent, well-rounded hotel in Berlin.
💰 Best Value
#3 Berlin Village Inn
9.1 rating, 600+ reviews, sun terrace, and free parking at the best price-to-quality ratio in the list.
🏠 Best for Self-Catering
#8 Barnwood Suite – Main Street Lodge
9.6 rating, 9.8 location, full kitchen, spa bath, and fireplace — the best apartment for cooking your own meals.
Check Tonight’s Price for Barnwood Suite – Main Street Lodge in Berlin →
How We Ranked These Amish Country Hotels
I evaluated 17 Berlin properties using Booking.com guest score data, focusing on properties with 10+ verified reviews and location scores above 8.0. Each review is based on live guest feedback, not marketing claims.
- Guest score thresholds: Only properties with 8.0+ overall and 10+ verified reviews
- Score breakdown analysis: Prioritized cleanliness, location, and value — the categories that drive repeat bookings
- Amenity verification: Cross-referenced advertised amenities against guest review patterns
- Location signals: Distance to Berlin’s Main Street shops and attractions
Frequently Asked Questions
Are pets allowed at any of these Amish Country hotels?
Yes — Lodging on the Square (H6) is pet-friendly and centrally located with a 9.3 location score. It’s the only central Berlin hotel on this list that explicitly allows pets. Some Main Street Lodge apartments and cottages may allow pets on request, but you’ll need to confirm directly at booking. Always check the pet policy and any additional fees before reserving.
Which hotels offer free cancellation?
Cancellation policies vary by property and booking date. Most Berlin hotels offer free cancellation up to 24-48 hours before check-in, but this changes with seasonal demand. The Berlin Heritage Inn, Berlin Grande Hotel, and Comfort Suites typically offer flexible rates. Always check the cancellation terms displayed during checkout — they’re property-specific.
When’s the best time to visit Amish Country in Ohio?
May through October offers the best weather for exploring Berlin’s shops, the Holmes County Amish Flea Market, and Heini’s Cheese Chalet. Fall foliage in October is spectacular. Spring and fall have moderate prices and fewer crowds. Winter is quiet but some properties close their pools. Book at least 2 weeks ahead for fall weekends — Berlin’s popularity is growing fast.
Which Main Street Lodge apartment has the best location?
Two apartments score a perfect 10.0 for location: the Magnolia Suite (H14) and the Sycamore Suite (H17). Both are on East Main Street in the same building complex. The Hickory Suite (H15) and Barnwood Suite (H8) tie at 9.8. For practical walkability to Berlin’s restaurants and shops, any of these four puts you at the center of everything.
Which hotels have kitchens or kitchenettes for self-catering?
Several properties offer cooking facilities. For full kitchens, the Barnwood Suite (H8), Historic Raber House (H10), Maple Suite (H13), Magnolia Suite (H14), Hickory Suite (H15), and Sycamore Suite (H17) all have fully equipped kitchens. Kitchenettes with stovetops are available at Blessing Lodge (H7), Coblentz Country Lodge (H12), and Premier Cottages (H16). The Berlin Grande Hotel and Comfort Suites have microwaves and refrigerators only.
Can I check in late at any of these Berlin properties?
Yes — the Berlin Heritage Inn (H1), Berlin Encore Hotel (H5), Lodging on the Square (H6), and Coblentz Country Lodge (H12) all accept check-in until midnight (00:00). The Berlin Grande Hotel and Comfort Suites have standard 15:00 check-in but can often accommodate late arrivals with advance notice. The Berlin Village Inn (H3) closes check-in at 21:00, and Blessing Lodge (H7) at 21:00 — plan accordingly for those two.