Santa Croce 14 B&B leads with a perfect 10.0 staff and location score, set right on Piazza Santa Croce. For a free-parking base with incredible hospitality near Pisa, Hotel Miratorre superior’s 9.7 staff score and garden setting are hard to beat.
Forget the tired lists. These 20 properties across Tuscany—from Florence’s iconic centers to Siena’s medieval lanes—earn their spot through real guest scores, not marketing fluff.
Why Trust This Guide
I analyzed 20,000+ verified reviews across these 20 Tuscan properties, prioritizing cleanliness scores of 9.3+, location ratings of 9.0+, and genuine staff hospitality metrics to cut through the noise.
???? Quick Picks: Skip to What You Need
- Top Luxury & Service: #13 Hotel David→ Rates
#4 Hotel La Gemma→ Rates - Best for Solo & Couples: #9 Renascentia in Florence→ Rates
- Families & Groups: #6 Hotel Miratorre superior→ Rates
#3 II Guelfo Bianco→ Rates - Perfect Location & View: #18 Santa Croce 14 B&B→ Rates
- Budget-Friendly with Parking: #13 Hotel David→ Rates
- Free Breakfast Excellence: #3 II Guelfo Bianco→ Rates
Editor’s Note on Booking: We use smart routing to find you the best available rates. Clicking our availability buttons checks live pricing across trusted platforms to ensure you secure your stay.
Quick Compare: Top Places To Stay
| Property | Rating | Book |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Casual Rinascimento Firenze by Casual Hoteles | (2600+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 2. BB Hotels Smarthotel Derose | (1950+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 3. II Guelfo Bianco | (1900+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 4. Hotel La Gemma | (1550+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 5. Hotel La Gemma | (1550+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 6. Hotel Miratorre superior | (1350+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 7. Ruby Bea Hotel Florence | (1250+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 8. Hotel Adamas | (1250+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 9. Renascentia in Florence – Adults Only | (1200+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 10. I Merli di Ada | (1100+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 11. 4F Boutique Hotel Florence | (1050+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 12. Essence Hotel | (1050+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 13. Hotel David | (1050+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 14. Palazzo dei Conti Residenza d’Epoca | (950+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 15. Canto degli Aranci | (800+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 16. Guicciardini 24 | (650+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 17. FuordArno Bed & Breakfast | (650+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 18. Santa Croce 14 B&B | (600+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 19. B&B La Signoria Di Firenze | (550+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 20. Peruzzi Urban Residences | (450+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
Detailed Reviews: Top Places to Stay Across Tuscany
1. Casual Rinascimento Firenze by Casual Hoteles
The Vibe
Three minutes from Piazza della Signoria, this modern hotel packs a surprising indoor pool and full spa—rare in central Florence. The 9.8 location score means you’re steps from the Uffizi. Staff warmth hits 9.6, and they even let pets in (charges apply). Cleanliness holds steady at 9.3.
What You Actually Get
Beyond the pool, you get a fitness center, airport shuttle, and family rooms—though kids 5+ are charged as adults. Free cribs are available. Breakfast scores well with guests. The kitchen access in some units adds flexibility. Wi-Fi runs a strong 9.2. Parking exists but is limited; book early. Groups booking more than 3 rooms face different policies, so check ahead.
Choose this if: you want a swim after museum-hopping—this is one of the few central hotels with a real indoor pool.
Check Tonight’s Price for Casual Rinascimento Firenze by Casual HotelesHotel in Florence →
2. BB Hotels Smarthotel Derose
The Vibe
A 4-star stay in Santa Maria Novella with a 9.6 cleanliness score that beats most competitors. The 9.2 rating across 1950 reviews signals consistency. Elevator access is a plus in Florence’s often walk-up world, and the value score of 9.1 means you’re not overpaying.
What You Actually Get
Air-conditioned rooms with daily housekeeping and a tea/coffee maker in every unit—small luxury, big difference. Upper floors are elevator-accessible. No pets allowed. Children 3+ are charged as adults. The 9.1 location score puts you near Santa Maria Novella train station, making day trips easy. Wi-Fi hits 8.9—solid but not stellar.
Choose this if: spotless rooms and a quiet Santa Maria Novella base matter more than a view.
Check Tonight’s Price for BB Hotels Smarthotel DeroseHotel in Florence →
3. II Guelfo Bianco
The Vibe
Family favorite with a 9.7 staff score and central San Lorenzo location. The 9.8 location score puts you a short walk from the Duomo and Mercato Centrale. Guests consistently praise the buffet breakfast—gluten-free options available. Value score of 9.1 keeps it accessible.
What You Actually Get
Family rooms, 24-hour front desk, and facilities for disabled guests. Free cribs on request. Children 2+ are charged as adults. The excellent breakfast includes continental and Italian spreads. Wi-Fi runs 9.0. No pets. The 9.5 cleanliness score keeps standards high. Groups welcome—ideal for multi-generational trips.
Choose this if: traveling with family and want a central base with exceptional morning spreads.
Check Tonight’s Price for II Guelfo BiancoHotel in Florence →
4. & 5. Hotel La Gemma
The Vibe
Five-star elegance with a 9.9 location score near Santa Maria Novella. The 9.8 comfort score and 9.7 cleanliness prove luxury isn’t just marketing. Two restaurants, a spa, sauna, and wellness center make this a full retreat. World-class service—guests call it “celebrity treatment.” Private parking in central Florence? Rare and valuable.
What You Actually Get
Air-conditioned rooms with private bathrooms, soundproofing, and free Wi-Fi (9.4). Room service, facilities for disabled guests, and a wonderful breakfast spread. Pets allowed on request with charges. Children welcome—add them to your search for exact pricing. Cribs available. Groups booking 7+ rooms face different policies. A damage deposit applies.
Choose this if: you want 5-star service, a spa, and the rare ability to park your rental car on-site.
6. Hotel Miratorre superior
The Vibe
Free parking near Pisa? Yes—and with a 9.7 staff score, this 3-star punches above its weight. The garden and terrace give it a relaxed feel, while a 9.4 cleanliness score keeps standards high. Family-run warmth shows in every review. Location score of 9.0 reflects its best-rated area status.
What You Actually Get
Tea/coffee maker in all rooms, free Wi-Fi (9.0), and free parking—rare in Tuscany. Family rooms, facilities for disabled guests, and a very good breakfast. Children 5+ charged as adults. No pets. Luggage storage available. The garden is a quiet retreat after Pisa’s crowds. A 3-star with 4-star hospitality.
Choose this if: you’re driving through Tuscany and need secure, free parking with genuine hospitality.
Check Tonight’s Price for Hotel Miratorre superiorHotel in Pisa →
7. Ruby Bea Hotel Florence
The Vibe
Campo Di Marte offers a quieter Florence experience without sacrificing access. The 9.6 staff score and 9.5 cleanliness/comfort ratings show consistent quality. An 8-minute walk to San Marco Church puts the historic center within reach. Good breakfast included.
What You Actually Get
Family rooms, parking, 24-hour front desk, elevator, and air conditioning. Children 4+ charged as adults. No pets. Groups booking 9+ rooms face different policies. Wi-Fi runs 9.2. The Campo Di Marte area is residential and authentic—less touristy than Santa Maria Novella. Good breakfast included.
Choose this if: you prefer quieter neighborhoods but still want the center within a 15-minute walk.
Check Tonight’s Price for Ruby Bea Hotel FlorenceHotel in Florence →
8. Hotel Adamas
The Vibe
On Via Ricasoli, steps from the Duomo and Piazza della Signoria, with a 9.9 location score that’s among the highest in Florence. Family-friendly with a 9.4 staff score. The 9.5 comfort score suggests solid sleep quality. Check-in ends at 8:30 PM—plan your arrival.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi (8.9), elevator, daily housekeeping, air conditioning, and baggage storage. Children 3+ charged as adults. No pets. Breakfast included—continental, Italian, and buffet options. The Duomo district location means you’re surrounded by Renaissance masterpieces. Restaurant reservations can be arranged.
Choose this if: the Duomo being a 2-minute walk is your priority—location doesn’t get better.
9. Renascentia in Florence – Adults Only
The Vibe
Adults-only haven 250 meters from the Cathedral of Santa Maria del Fiore and Piazza del Duomo. The 9.9 staff and location scores create an almost flawless experience. Cleanliness hits 9.8, comfort 9.8, facilities 9.6—every metric is exceptional. 1200 reviews confirm consistency, not luck.
What You Actually Get
Private bathrooms with showers, free toiletries, hair dryer, flat-screen TV, and free Wi-Fi (9.7). Continental, Italian, and gluten-free breakfast options. No children allowed—strictly adults only. No cots or extra beds. Check-in 3-7 PM only; late arrivals need advance notice. The property sits above a restaurant in a historic building.
Choose this if: you’re a couple or solo traveler seeking quiet luxury steps from Florence’s icons—it’s worth booking early.
Check Tonight’s Price for Renascentia in Florence – Adults Only →
10. I Merli di Ada
The Vibe
Siena’s medieval heart, with a 9.7 location score on Via San Martino. The 9.5 staff score and exceptional breakfast make this a base for exploring the Palio city. Private parking in Siena’s restricted center is a major advantage. City and landmark views from some rooms.
What You Actually Get
Air-conditioned rooms, free Wi-Fi (8.7), private parking, room service, airport shuttle, and family rooms. Exceptional breakfast at €15. Upper floors accessible by elevator. Pets allowed on request with charges. Children welcome—add ages for pricing. Check-in ends at 6:30 PM; plan accordingly.
Choose this if: you’re visiting Siena with a car and want secure parking steps from Piazza del Campo.
11. 4F Boutique Hotel Florence
The Vibe
Boutique charm on the Lungarno Amerigo Vespucci—Florence’s riverside promenade. The 9.7 staff score and 9.6 cleanliness/comfort scores reflect meticulous attention. A 14-minute walk to Santa Maria Novella train station makes it practical. Private parking available. Wonderful breakfast.
What You Actually Get
Terrace views, room service, airport shuttle, facilities for disabled guests, and free Wi-Fi (9.5). Private parking—rare along the Arno. Cribs available on request. No pets. Check-in until 10 PM gives flexibility. The 9.3 location puts you between the historic center and the Oltrarno.
Choose this if: you want boutique character with Arno views and train station proximity.
Check Tonight’s Price for 4F Boutique Hotel FlorenceHotel in Florence →
12. Essence Hotel
The Vibe
Piazza della Indipendenza location with the highest Wi-Fi score in this list—9.8. The 9.6 staff score and 9.5 comfort make it a solid choice for remote workers. Terrace and shared lounge add communal space. Private parking available. City views from some rooms.
What You Actually Get
Air-conditioned rooms, free Wi-Fi (9.8—bring your video calls), elevator, heating, family rooms, and designated smoking area. Children 4+ charged as adults. No pets. Free cribs available. Private parking. Check-in ends at 7:30 PM—arrive early. The Indipendenza area is quieter than the tourist core.
Choose this if: reliable, fast internet is non-negotiable for your trip.
13. Hotel David
The Vibe
Legendary hospitality at Viale Michelangelo—free happy hour with drinks and snacks, free minibar, and free parking. The 9.9 staff score makes this one of Florence’s most beloved properties. A 5-minute bus ride to the historic center. Antique furniture and artwork give rooms character. 9.8 cleanliness and 9.7 facilities.
What You Actually Get
Free private parking—huge. Free minibar restocked daily. Free Wi-Fi (9.7). Air conditioning, satellite TV, garden access. Pets allowed free—no extra charges. Children welcome—add ages for pricing. Breakfast includes continental, Italian, vegetarian, vegan, gluten-free, and American options. The garden happy hour is a daily ritual.
Choose this if: you want exceptional value with free parking, free drinks, and pet-friendly policies—this is the best deal in Florence.
14. Palazzo dei Conti Residenza d’Epoca
The Vibe
Historic residence on Via dei Conti with a 9.9 location and 9.8 staff/comfort scores. Parquet floors, terrace with city views, soundproofed rooms—this is old-world Florence done right. The 9.7 cleanliness and 9.5 facilities confirm quality. Private parking available. Continental breakfast.
What You Actually Get
Air-conditioned rooms with minibars, soundproofing, free Wi-Fi (9.4), and private bathrooms. Family rooms with sofa beds available. Children 4+ charged as adults. No pets. English, Spanish, and French spoken at reception. Note: no breakfast from February 5-18, 2026. The terrace offers panoramic city views.
Choose this if: you want historic character, soundproofed rooms, and a 9.9 location in Santa Maria Novella.
Check Tonight’s Price for Palazzo dei Conti Residenza d’Epoca →
15. Canto degli Aranci
The Vibe
Near Piazza della Signoria with a 9.9 staff score and spotless 9.9 cleanliness—this B&B on Via Giuseppe Verdi is meticulous. Uffizi gallery sits 8 minutes away, Ponte Vecchio within 1 km. The 9.7 facilities and 9.5 Wi-Fi support a seamless stay. Continental, Italian, and gluten-free breakfast options.
What You Actually Get
Air-conditioned rooms with private bathrooms, free Wi-Fi (9.5), kitchen access, and living areas. Children 18+ charged as adults. No pets. English, French, and Italian spoken. Note: lift available from 1st floor via 34 steps. Late arrival fee €50 from 8 PM-midnight. Parking available nearby.
Choose this if: you prioritize pristine rooms and a central Uffizi neighborhood location.
16. Guicciardini 24
The Vibe
Santo Spirito location with Ponte Vecchio less than 200 meters away—you can hear the Arno from your window. The 9.9 location and 9.8 staff scores are elite. Contemporary black-and-white decor with air conditioning. A 5-minute walk to Palazzo Pitti and Boboli Gardens. 9.8 cleanliness and 9.7 comfort.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi (9.2), private bathrooms, flat-screen TV, kitchen access, and city views. No children allowed—adults only. No cots or extra beds. English and Italian spoken. Some Florence streets have duplicate house numbers—use the map, not just the address. Available 10 AM-1 PM for inquiries.
Choose this if: you want to be steps from Ponte Vecchio in a stylish, adults-only guesthouse.
17. FuordArno Bed & Breakfast
The Vibe
Top-floor B&B on Lungarno Torrigiani with a 9.9 staff and location score—and a 9.7 overall rating, the second-highest in this list. River views from some rooms, Ponte Vecchio 500 meters away. The 9.8 cleanliness and comfort scores reflect obsessive attention. Italian, vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free breakfast options.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi (9.3), seating areas in some rooms, coffee-making facilities, and river or city views. No elevator—64 steps to the top floor. Late arrival fees apply: €10 from 8-10 PM, €20 after 10 PM. Children 3+ charged as adults. No pets. Kitchen access available.
Choose this if: you want exceptional hosting and Arno views without the hotel markup.
18. Santa Croce 14 B&B
The Vibe
The highest-rated property in this list—9.8 overall with perfect 10.0 scores in staff, location, cleanliness, and Wi-Fi. Set directly on Piazza Santa Croce, with the basilica at your doorstep. Only 600 reviews, but every metric is elite. Italian breakfast served at the bar/pastry shop downstairs.
What You Actually Get
Air-conditioned rooms with private bathrooms, tea/coffee makers, free Wi-Fi (10.0), and balconies in some rooms. Kitchen access. Children 12+ welcome. No pets. Check-in 2-6 PM; advance notice required for timing. The bar downstairs handles breakfast—fresh pastries and coffee. Piazza Santa Croce location is one of Florence’s best.
Choose this if: you want the highest-rated B&B in Florence on one of its most beautiful piazzas.
19. B&B La Signoria Di Firenze
The Vibe
Twenty meters from Piazza della Signoria—you’re essentially sleeping on the square. The 10.0 location score is literal. Modern rooms with free Wi-Fi (7.8—the weak link here) and LCD TVs. The 9.9 staff and 9.7 cleanliness/comfort scores show passion. Comfy beds praised by guests. 24-hour check-in flexibility.
What You Actually Get
Air-conditioned rooms, private bathrooms, free Wi-Fi, kitchen access, and city views. Children 18+ charged as adults. No pets. English, French, and Italian spoken. Breakfast buffet with free newspapers available. A damage deposit may apply. Late arrivals must coordinate in advance despite 24-hour check-in.
Choose this if: being in the absolute center of Florence with flexible check-in is your priority—just don’t rely on fast Wi-Fi.
20. Peruzzi Urban Residences
The Vibe
On Piazza dei Peruzzi in the Uffizi district, this historic residence offers a unique stay with parquet floors and original character. The 9.9 staff score and 9.8 Wi-Fi (9.8—excellent) make it practical for extended stays. Shared kitchen adds home-like flexibility. Private entrance for independence.
What You Actually Get
Air-conditioned rooms with private bathrooms, free Wi-Fi (9.8), shared kitchen, bar, and paid shuttle service. Lift available. Pets allowed on request with charges. Children 4+ charged as adults. English spoken. Continental and buffet breakfast options. Check-in until midnight offers flexibility. Concierge service available.
Choose this if: you want a historic apartment feel with shared kitchen access and late check-in flexibility.
Final Verdict: Our Top 3 Picks
???? Best Overall
#18 Santa Croce 14 B&B
Perfect 10.0 scores across staff, location, cleanliness, and Wi-Fi—the highest-rated property in this list with 600+ reviews confirming elite consistency.
???? Best Value
#13 Hotel David
Free parking, free minibar, free happy hour, free pets—a 9.6 overall rating with phenomenal value that no other property in this list matches.
???????????? Best for Families
#3 II Guelfo Bianco
Family rooms, excellent breakfast with gluten-free options, 9.8 location, and a 9.7 staff score that makes parents and kids feel equally welcome.
Check Tonight’s Price for II Guelfo BiancoHotel in Florence →
How We Ranked These Tuscany Hotels
This guide is built from 20,000+ verified guest reviews across 20 Tuscan properties. We prioritized real traveler feedback over marketing claims, cross-referencing every score, policy, and amenity against actual guest patterns.
- Guest score thresholds: Only properties with 8.0+ overall and 10+ verified reviews
- Score breakdown analysis: Prioritized cleanliness, location, and value—the categories that drive repeat bookings
- Amenity verification: Cross-referenced advertised amenities against guest review patterns
- Location signals: Proximity to Duomo, Piazza della Signoria, Santa Maria Novella, and key Tuscan landmarks
Frequently Asked Questions
Are pets allowed at any of these Tuscany hotels?
Yes, several properties welcome pets. Hotel La Gemma and Casual Rinascimento Firenze allow pets on request with charges. Hotel David offers the best deal—pets stay free with no extra fees. Peruzzi Urban Residences and I Merli di Ada also accept pets on request with applicable charges. The remaining 15 properties in this list do not allow pets.
Which hotels offer free cancellation?
Most properties in this list have cancellation and prepayment policies that vary by room type. Santa Croce 14 B&B, FuordArno B&B, and Guicciardini 24 offer more flexible cancellation through certain rate plans. We recommend checking the specific conditions for your dates before booking—filter by “free cancellation” on the booking page to see eligible rooms.
What’s the best time to visit Tuscany for hotel deals?
April-May and September-October offer the best balance of pleasant weather and lower rates. July and August see peak prices and crowds, especially in Florence and Siena. For the best value, consider November (excluding holidays) or March, when many of the best hotels in Tuscany drop rates by 20-30%. Hotel David’s year-round free parking and happy hour make it a consistent value pick regardless of season.
Which area of Tuscany is most walkable?
Florence’s historic center is the most walkable—properties near Santa Maria Novella (Hotel La Gemma, Palazzo dei Conti), the Duomo (Hotel Adamas), or Piazza della Signoria (B&B La Signoria Di Firenze) put everything within a 10-15 minute walk. Siena’s compact center, served by I Merli di Ada, is also highly walkable but hillier. For drivers, Hotel Miratorre superior near Pisa and Hotel David at Viale Michelangelo offer free parking with easy access.
How do I get from Florence Airport to these hotels?
Florence’s Amerigo Vespucci Airport (FLR) is just 4 km from the center. The Volainbus shuttle runs every 30 minutes to Santa Maria Novella train station (€6, 20 minutes). Hotels near Santa Maria Novella like BB Hotels Smarthotel Derose (9.2 rating) and Hotel La Gemma are a short walk from the station. Hotels in the Uffizi district like Casual Rinascimento Firenze and Renascentia are a 10-minute walk or quick taxi ride. Taxis cost €20-25 flat rate from the airport.
Which of these hotels has the best breakfast?
II Guelfo Bianco, Hotel David, and I Merli di Ada all offer breakfast spreads praised by guests. II Guelfo Bianco provides gluten-free and buffet options. Hotel David offers continental, Italian, vegetarian, vegan, gluten-free, and American choices. I Merli di Ada serves an “exceptional” Italian breakfast. For a unique experience, Santa Croce 14 B&B sends you to the pastry shop downstairs—fresh cornetti on the piazza.