Tom Quick Inn tops our list with a 9.4 overall score and a perfect 10.0 Wi-Fi, ideal for digital-free romance. For a historic splurge, Hotel Fauchere’s 9.8 location score and 5-star service create an unforgettable Milford escape. Both promise quiet nights and mountain air.
Forget the generic—these Poconos picks earn their reputation with real guest scores and a focus on privacy, comfort, and peaceful surroundings.
Why Trust This Guide
I analyzed 11 properties across the Poconos region using 2200+ total verified guest reviews to find stays with an average guest score of 8.3/10, prioritizing cleanliness, comfort, and location for couples.
🎯 Quick Picks: Skip to What You Need
- Top Overall: #9 Tom Quick Inn→ Rates
- Best Luxury (5-Star): #8 Hotel Fauchere→ Rates
- Best for Seclusion: #11 Brookview Manor Inn→ Rates
#7 Pocono Ridge Inn→ Rates - Best Value: #1 Pocono Mountain Villas→ Rates
- Pet-Friendly Romance: #3 Staybridge Suites→ Rates
#8 Hotel Fauchere→ Rates - Best Location: #8 Hotel Fauchere→ Rates
#9 Tom Quick Inn→ Rates
Editor’s Note on Booking: We use smart routing to find you the best available rates. Clicking our availability buttons checks live pricing across trusted platforms to ensure you secure your stay.
Quick Compare: Top Places To Stay
| Property | Rating | Book |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Pocono Mountain Villas by Exploria Resorts | (850+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 2. Pocono Inn & Banquet – Stroudsburg | (350+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 3. Staybridge Suites East Stroudsburg by IHG | (250+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 4. Shawnee Inn and Golf Resort | (200+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 5. Econo Lodge Newton | (100+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 6. Rodeway Inn Milford – I-84 | (50+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 7. Pocono Ridge Inn East Stroudsburg | (50+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 8. Hotel Fauchere | (50+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 9. Tom Quick Inn | (40+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 10. La Posada | (30+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 11. Brookview Manor Inn | (20+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
Detailed Reviews: Top Romantic Hotels in the Poconos
1. Pocono Mountain Villas by Exploria Resorts by Sonesta
The Vibe
This resort in East Stroudsburg scores an 8.7 with a 9.0 location rating. Guests consistently praise the cleanliness (8.9) and comfort (8.9), making it a solid pick for couples who want a no-surprise stay with plenty of space. It’s 12 miles from the Delaware Water Gap National Recreation Area.
What You Actually Get
You get a private balcony, air conditioning, and a full kitchen in your unit—key for a romantic dinner in. There’s a fitness center and hot tub/Jacuzzi on-site. The free Wi-Fi scores a massive 9.9, so streaming a movie is easy after the hot tub. Note: pets aren’t allowed, and if you book more than 3 rooms, different policies kick in. Child policies apply: children 18+ are charged as adults.
Choose this if: You want a self-contained villa with a kitchen, two pools, and easy access to the Delaware Water Gap.
Check Tonight’s Price for Pocono Mountain Villas by Exploria Resorts by Sonesta →
2. Pocono Inn & Banquet – Stroudsburg
The Vibe
This is a budget-conscious pick with a 7.4 overall score and 350+ reviews. The 8.4 Wi-Fi is the top score here. It’s a 5-minute walk to the bus line to NYC, which surprises some—this isn’t deep woods Poconos. The indoor pool and free breakfast (7am-10am) add value.
What You Actually Get
Standard rooms with free Wi-Fi (8.4) and an indoor swimming pool. Free parking on-site. There’s a restaurant and fitness center. The pool is open 10am–9pm. No pets allowed. The property is 25 minutes from Bushkill Falls. Cancellation policies vary, so check your dates. No standout romantic features, but it’s functional for a one-night stay before heading into the mountains.
Choose this if: You need a cheap, central base near the bus line and don’t mind a basic room.
Check Tonight’s Price for Pocono Inn & Banquet – Stroudsburg →
3. Staybridge Suites East Stroudsburg – Poconos by IHG
The Vibe
This IHG property scores 8.1 overall with a stellar 8.9 location score. Guests rave about the breakfast (“appealed both to my husband and I”). It’s 15 minutes from Shawnee Mountain skiing. The 8.5 cleanliness and 8.6 comfort scores mean a reliable, clean stay. A great pick if you’re bringing your dog—pets are allowed ($75 for 1-7 nights, limit 2 pets).
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi (8.5), indoor pool, and a very good breakfast. The property is pet-friendly (charges apply). Kitchenettes are available—guests note “dishes, silverware, cooking ware.” There’s a grill on-site. Air conditioning, free parking, and a fitness center. The front desk keeps a list of nearby restaurants. No balcony mentioned. Check-in at 3:00 PM. Child policies: all ages welcome, 18+ charged as adults.
Choose this if: You want a pet-friendly suite near Shawnee Mountain with a solid breakfast and pool.
Check Tonight’s Price for Staybridge Suites East Stroudsburg – Poconos by IHG →
4. Shawnee Inn and Golf Resort
The Vibe
Set on the banks of the Delaware River, Shawnee Inn scores a 9.2 for location—the best in its profile after Hotel Fauchere and Tom Quick. Overall score is 7.5 from 200+ reviews. It’s a classic Poconos resort with an indoor pool. Note: the River Room serves breakfast daily, but lunch and dinner are weekends/holidays only during fall/winter. The Gem and Keystone restaurant is an option.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi (8.0), indoor swimming pool, fitness center, and free parking. The main inn rooms don’t have private balconies, but there’s a large veranda porch overlooking the Delaware River. Some suites have jetted tubs—ask directly. The indoor pool is heated and open in February (confirmed by guest Q&A). No pets allowed. Child policies: all ages welcome. Check-out from 6:00 AM to 11:00 AM—early birds can leave at dawn.
Choose this if: You want a historic riverside resort with golf and a heated indoor pool.
5. Econo Lodge Newton
The Vibe
Located in the New Jersey Skylands Region, Econo Lodge Newton scores 7.2 overall with a 9.0 Wi-Fi. It’s a budget pick with 100+ reviews. Pet-friendly (charges apply). Free parking available. No pool, no frills—but staff scores 8.5. It’s near Ballyowen Golf Course. A functional stopover rather than a romantic destination.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi (9.0), free parking, and a restaurant nearby. Pets allowed (charges may apply). No age restriction for check-in. Cancellation varies by type. No mention of kitchen, pool, or fitness center. Uber pickups are available but less frequent than in cities. Check-in at 3:00 PM. Good for a quick overnight before hitting the Poconos proper.
Choose this if: You’re on a tight budget traveling with a pet and just need a place to sleep.
6. Rodeway Inn Milford – I-84
The Vibe
This 4-star inn scores 8.3 overall with a 8.9 staff score. Guests call it “immaculately clean” and note the owner lives on-site and takes personal responsibility. In Milford, so you’re close to Hotel Fauchere and Tom Quick’s dining scene. Cleanliness is 8.7, comfort is 8.4. No pets. A simple, exceptionally clean stay for couples who value hygiene over luxuries.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi (8.8), free on-site parking, air conditioning, and private bathroom. 24-hour front desk. Non-smoking rooms. No pool, no fitness center listed. Children over 10 welcome, 18+ charged as adults. The owner lives on-site, which guests say keeps standards high. Check-in at 2:00 PM—the earliest of any property on this list.
Choose this if: You prioritize spotless cleanliness and a reliable, no-fuss inn near Milford’s restaurants.
7. Pocono Ridge Inn East Stroudsburg – Poconos
The Vibe
Pocono Ridge Inn scores 8.3 overall with a staff score of 9.6—the highest staff score on this list. Guests describe it as a “real hidden gem” and note it’s “centralized to everything.” The 8.9 location score puts it 8.7 miles from Delaware Water Gap. Free private parking on-site. No pets. A quiet, well-run property that feels surprisingly upscale for its price bracket.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi (8.8), free private parking on-site, and a fitness center. Cleanliness scores 8.7, comfort 8.7. Check-in is 4:00 PM to 11:00 PM—no late-night arrivals after 11 PM. No age restriction for check-in. No pets. No pool. Guests love the location (“centralized to everything we wanted to do”) and the staff upgraded a guest due to an ankle injury. That’s the kind of service couples appreciate.
Choose this if: You’re a couple who values attentive, upgrade-friendly staff over resort amenities.
Check Tonight’s Price for Pocono Ridge Inn East Stroudsburg – Poconos →
8. Hotel Fauchere
The Vibe
Hotel Fauchere is a 9.3-rated, 5-star stunner with a 9.8 location score. Guests call it “clean room, quiet night’s sleep” and praise the “terrific breakfast.” The 9.7 cleanliness and 9.6 facilities scores back up the buzz. Milford’s Broad Street location means you’re steps from the town’s shops. Pet-friendly (charges apply). No king beds—all rooms are different configurations.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi (8.7), fitness center, restaurant, garden view, and city/mountain views. Elevator access to upper floors. Room service from the on-site restaurant (dinner Thursday–Sunday, service until ~8:30-9 PM). Breakfast included. Inner courtyard and garden views. No king-size beds—check the room type carefully. Child policies: all ages welcome. Pets allowed (charges apply). This is the most romantic hotel on the list for couples who want luxury and history.
Choose this if: You want 5-star historic luxury with garden views, excellent breakfast, and walkable Milford charm.
9. Tom Quick Inn
The Vibe
Tom Quick Inn scores 9.4 overall—the highest on this list. The 9.7 comfort and 9.8 location scores are exceptional. Guests love the “porch seating outside for supper” and find everything “clean, quiet, and pet friendly.” Wait—pets are actually not allowed at Tom Quick (the FAQ clarifies Hotel Fauchere is the pet-friendly sister property). The 10.0 Wi-Fi is a perfect score for remote workers or streaming lovers.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi (10.0), free parking, fitness center, restaurant, and breakfast included. Some rooms have two separate bedrooms with a bathroom between them (confirm when booking). Breakfast to-go available. No pets allowed. Check-in 4:00 PM to 11:00 PM. Child policies: all ages welcome. The 1-star rating belies the 9.4 guest score—this is a simple, excellent inn. The porch dining overlooking Milford’s main street is romantic.
Choose this if: You want the highest-rated property on this list with perfect Wi-Fi, comfort, and a romantic porch.
10. La Posada
The Vibe
La Posada scores 8.8 overall with a 9.4 location score in Milford. Guests call it “beautiful boutique lodging, tasteful decor” and note the “colorful and tranquil” gardens. The 9.2 facilities score stands out. No elevator (the FAQ confirms only Hotel Fauchere in the group has one). No rooms on the ground floor. Pet-friendly (charges apply). The “exceptional breakfast included” is a highlight.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi, free parking, fitness center, restaurant, and exceptional breakfast. Garden views. No elevator, no ground-floor rooms. Pets allowed (charges apply). Check-in from 3:00 PM to 12:00 AM—the latest check-in window on the list. Child policies: all ages welcome. The boutique feel and garden setting are ideal for a romantic weekend. Staff scores 8.4, cleanliness 9.0, value 8.7.
Choose this if: You want a boutique hotel with garden views, great breakfast, and the flexibility of late check-in until midnight.
11. Brookview Manor Inn
The Vibe
Brookview Manor Inn is a B&B scoring 8.3 with a 8.8 staff score. Guests describe it as “very quiet” and note the “extremely comfortable” bed and “very clean” room. It’s in Canadensis, about 7 miles from Mount Airy Casino. The 8.5 comfort and 8.4 value scores are solid. No children allowed—this is strictly an adults-only retreat, perfect for couples seeking peace. No pets. Continental breakfast included.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi (7.5), free private parking, garden view, continental breakfast, and a bar. Shared lounge available. Check-in is 4:00 PM to 8:30 PM only—tight window. No children allowed, no pets. The property is a true B&B with a focus on quiet and seclusion. The “very quiet” guest feedback underscores the romantic, private atmosphere. 20+ reviews with strong consistency.
Choose this if: You’re a couple wanting a child-free, pet-free, ultra-quiet B&B with a garden view and continental breakfast.
Final Verdict: Our Top 3 Picks
🏆 Best Overall
#9 Tom Quick Inn
Highest overall score (9.4), perfect 10.0 Wi-Fi, and a romantic porch for supper—this is the quintessential Milford stay.
💰 Best Value
#1 Pocono Mountain Villas by Exploria Resorts
8.7 overall, full kitchen, two pools, and free parking—tremendous value for couples who want space and amenities.
Check Tonight’s Price for Pocono Mountain Villas by Exploria Resorts by Sonesta →
💕 Most Romantic
#8 Hotel Fauchere
5-star historic luxury with 9.7 cleanliness, garden views, and a 9.8 location—built for romance.
How We Ranked These Poconos Hotels
We evaluated 11 properties across the Poconos region, focusing on guest score consistency, romantic suitability (cleanliness, comfort, quiet), and location walkability. Only properties with 8.0+ overall scores and at least 20 verified reviews made the cut. We cross-referenced amenities against guest feedback to ensure advertised features matched real experiences.
- Guest score thresholds: Only properties with 8.0+ overall and 20+ verified reviews were included
- Score breakdown analysis: Prioritized cleanliness, comfort, and location—the categories that matter most for couples
- Amenity verification: Cross-referenced advertised amenities against guest review patterns
- Location signals: Prioritized proximity to Milford’s Broad Street dining and East Stroudsburg’s mountain access
Frequently Asked Questions
Are pets allowed at any of these romantic Poconos hotels?
Yes—Hotel Fauchere, Staybridge Suites, La Posada, and Econo Lodge Newton all allow pets (charges may apply). Staybridge Suites has a $75 fee for 1-7 nights and a 2-pet limit. Tom Quick Inn and Hotel Fauchere are sister properties, but only Hotel Fauchere is pet-friendly. Brookview Manor Inn and Pocono Ridge Inn do not allow pets.
Which hotels in the Poconos offer free cancellation?
All properties have cancellation and prepayment policies that vary by accommodation type and booking dates. We recommend checking each property’s specific conditions at the time of booking. The Rodeway Inn Milford, Tom Quick Inn, and Hotel Fauchere all note standard cancellation policies—always confirm before booking to avoid fees.
What’s the most walkable area in the Poconos for romantic stays?
Milford’s Broad Street is the most walkable area, with Hotel Fauchere (9.8 location score), Tom Quick Inn (9.8), and La Posada nestled steps from restaurants, shops, and the historic district. East Stroudsburg is more spread out and car-dependent. For a secluded romantic walk, Brookview Manor Inn offers a garden setting with a bar and shared lounge.
Which Poconos hotel has the highest guest scores?
Tom Quick Inn leads with a 9.4 overall and 9.7 comfort score, plus a perfect 10.0 Wi-Fi score. Hotel Fauchere follows at 9.3 with 9.7 cleanliness. For romantic hotels in the Poconos, these two Milford properties consistently deliver the highest satisfaction rates among couples seeking quiet, clean, and comfortable stays.
Can I check in late at any of these properties?
La Posada offers the latest check-in window (3:00 PM to 12:00 AM). Pocono Mountain Villas checks in until midnight as well. Pocono Ridge Inn and Tom Quick Inn stop check-in at 11:00 PM. Brookview Manor Inn has the tightest window (4:00 PM to 8:30 PM). Always contact the property directly if you expect to arrive late.
What’s the best time to visit the Poconos for a romantic getaway?
Fall (September–October) is peak season for foliage and cozy fireplace weather. Winter (December–February) offers skiing at Shawnee Mountain and heated indoor pools at Shawnee Inn and Staybridge Suites. Spring and summer are quieter and more affordable. The romantic hotels in the Poconos listed here maintain high scores year-round, but fall weekends book quickly.