Where to Eat in Mystic? Top Local Favorites

The charming coastal town of Mystic, Connecticut, is a popular destination for tourists and locals alike. Known for its rich maritime history, picturesque harbor, and vibrant arts scene, Mystic has something to offer for everyone. One of the most enjoyable aspects of visiting Mystic is the diverse and delicious dining scene. From seafood restaurants serving up fresh catches to cozy cafes serving up homemade treats, there’s no shortage of options for foodies to explore. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll take you on a culinary tour of Mystic, highlighting the top restaurants, cafes, and eateries that are not to be missed.

Seafood Restaurants

Mystic is renowned for its seafood, and for good reason. The town’s proximity to the ocean ensures that the freshest catches are always available. Here are some of the top seafood restaurants in Mystic:

The Oyster Club

Located in the heart of downtown Mystic, The Oyster Club is a seafood lover’s paradise. This upscale restaurant serves up a wide variety of fresh seafood, including oysters, lobster, and fish. Their menu changes seasonally, but be sure to try their famous seafood tower, which features a selection of the day’s freshest catches.

Mystic Drawbrd

Mystic Drawbrd is a casual, waterfront restaurant that serves up delicious seafood at reasonable prices. Their menu features a wide variety of options, including fish and chips, lobster rolls, and seafood pasta. They also offer a daily happy hour with discounted drinks and appetizers.

The Captain Daniel Packer Inne

This historic inn has been serving up seafood in Mystic for over 300 years. Their menu features a wide variety of options, including fish, shellfish, and lobster. Be sure to try their famous clam chowder, which is made with fresh clams and served with a side of oyster crackers.

Other Notable Seafood Restaurants

  • Red 36
  • Black Seal Brewing Company
  • Water’s Edge Restaurant

Cafes and Bakeries

Mystic is home to a number of charming cafes and bakeries that serve up delicious treats and coffee. Here are some of the top spots to check out:

The Mystic Coffee Company

This cozy coffee shop serves up a wide variety of coffee drinks, including lattes, cappuccinos, and cold brew. They also offer a selection of pastries, sandwiches, and salads.

The Daily Catch

This bakery and cafe serves up a wide variety of delicious treats, including pastries, sandwiches, and salads. They also offer a selection of coffee drinks and smoothies.

The Mystic Bakery

This family-owned bakery has been serving up delicious treats in Mystic for over 20 years. Their menu features a wide variety of options, including bread, pastries, and cakes.

Other Notable Cafes and Bakeries

  • The Coffee Pedlar
  • Madison’s
  • The Whaler’s Inn

Italian Restaurants

Mystic is home to a number of excellent Italian restaurants that serve up delicious pasta dishes, pizzas, and other Italian favorites. Here are some of the top spots to check out:

Frankie’s Ristorante

This family-owned Italian restaurant has been serving up delicious pasta dishes and pizzas in Mystic for over 20 years. Their menu features a wide variety of options, including vegetarian and gluten-free choices.

Sal’s Pizzeria

This casual pizzeria serves up delicious pies with a variety of toppings. They also offer a selection of salads, sandwiches, and pasta dishes.

La Bella Vita

This upscale Italian restaurant serves up delicious pasta dishes, pizzas, and other Italian favorites in a cozy and intimate setting.

Other Notable Italian Restaurants

  • Il Palio
  • Mamma Mia’s
  • La Famiglia

Other Notable Restaurants

Mystic is home to a number of other notable restaurants that serve up a wide variety of cuisines. Here are some of the top spots to check out:

The Whaler’s Inn

This historic inn has been serving up delicious American cuisine in Mystic for over 300 years. Their menu features a wide variety of options, including steaks, seafood, and pasta dishes.

The Captain’s Table

This upscale restaurant serves up delicious American cuisine in a cozy and intimate setting. Their menu features a wide variety of options, including steaks, seafood, and pasta dishes.

Red 36

This modern American bistro serves up delicious small plates and entrees in a trendy and lively atmosphere.

Other Notable Restaurants

  • The Mystic Grill
  • Black Seal Brewing Company
  • The Water’s Edge Restaurant

Recap

In this comprehensive guide, we’ve highlighted some of the top restaurants, cafes, and eateries in Mystic, Connecticut. From seafood restaurants serving up fresh catches to cozy cafes serving up homemade treats, there’s no shortage of options for foodies to explore. Whether you’re in the mood for Italian, American, or seafood cuisine, Mystic has something to offer for everyone.

Key Points

  • The Oyster Club is a must-visit for seafood lovers.
  • Mystic Drawbrd is a casual, waterfront restaurant that serves up delicious seafood at reasonable prices.
  • The Captain Daniel Packer Inne has been serving up seafood in Mystic for over 300 years.
  • The Mystic Coffee Company serves up a wide variety of coffee drinks and pastries.
  • Frankie’s Ristorante is a family-owned Italian restaurant that serves up delicious pasta dishes and pizzas.
  • The Whaler’s Inn has been serving up delicious American cuisine in Mystic for over 300 years.

FAQs

Where can I find the best seafood in Mystic?

The Oyster Club, Mystic Drawbrd, and The Captain Daniel Packer Inne are all highly recommended for their fresh seafood.

What are some good options for coffee and pastries in Mystic?

The Mystic Coffee Company, The Daily Catch, and The Mystic Bakery are all great options for coffee and pastries.

Where can I find good Italian food in Mystic?

Frankie’s Ristorante, Sal’s Pizzeria, and La Bella Vita are all highly recommended for their Italian cuisine.

What are some good options for American cuisine in Mystic?

The Whaler’s Inn, The Captain’s Table, and Red 36 are all great options for American cuisine.

Are there any good restaurants in Mystic that are open for breakfast?

Yes, many of the restaurants mentioned in this guide offer breakfast options, including The Mystic Coffee Company, The Daily Catch, and The Whaler’s Inn.